Thursday, October 7, 2010

Oh how I long for an acquaintance...

As others have been posting, this book is quite funny. And both Catherine and Mrs. Allens lack of an aquaintance in the beginning of the novel is the best part. They seem exceedingly desperate and needy. I have yet to understand why they would not just walk up to someone and make an aquaintance instead of complaining about it. But this is a digression. By the two characters, namely Catherine, longing for a friend, this makes the relationship between her and Isabella that more important. It causes the reader to pay special attention to how Catherine will interact with her "new acquintance." I am not exactly sure how everyone else feels about their relationship, but it seems a little rushed to me. By the end of the night, they were instant best friends. I was particularly taken back at what Catherine thought of Isabella as she was walking away. At the very end of chapter four, the narrator states that "Catherine then ran directly up stairs, and watched Miss Thorpe's progress down the street from the drawing-room window; admired the graceful spirit of her walk, the fashionable air of her figure and dress, and felt grateful, as well she might, for the chance which had produced her such a friend." The reader cannot help but to feel that Catherine is extraordinarily innocent. I am happy she found herself an acquaintance, but it just seems a little unrealistic given that they just met that afternoon. I am very interested in seeing how this relationship between the two friends plays out; especially since they honestly do not know each other that well.

2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree completely with you in that this friendship seems very rushed. I do think that this 'friendship', if it can be considered a friendship, is very shallow, much like most everything else in the book. I do believe that Catherine is very innocent and does believe that she and Isabella have a true friendship. However, Isabella seems very vain and selfish and seems to contradict herself all the time, saying that she would never leave Catherine and then abandons her to dance with James almost immediately after (43). Catherine admires Isabella's knowledge of the behaviors and fashions that belong to the upper class, but she does not see that Isabella is merely using her to get to her brother. I do think that Catherine believes that Isabella is trying to look out for her and help her to be successful in the world of adults. However, I think that Isabella is going to turn on Catherine at some point, and that will be where this book gets interesting. I do not think that this friendship will last, as it has no genuine base, and because it has been very shallow from the start and does not seem to be improving. I do want to see where this shallow friendship goes.

    ReplyDelete